i use mastodon with the same username of lemmy
but its great for me
what is your experience
I use it. It’s an OK way to share status updates.
I do wish it had more local communities though. Feels like some liberal pools have only adopted bluesky, which is kind of a sad state of affairs considering the ownership model is just as messy as any other public corp. Just because you add the word “benefit” to the title doesn’t mean it’s at all trust worthy lmao.
I’ll say the same thing as everyone else, but with different emphasis:
If I cared about “microblogging”-style social media, which I don’t, Mastodon would be the service I would use.
No, I don’t like the Twitter format.
I use Mastodon under the same username. I do this to support the network even though I’m not a fan of the microblog format. Thankfully most Mastodon servers allow unlimited post size, so its not such nonsense as Twitter was.
Its a good news feed in lieu of another network of its like. Between Lemmy and Mastodon I feel like I have my fill of social media.
I have an account, actually had it longer than lemmy I think, but only barely use it, mostly to post some of my drawings. I’m not really a fan of the “follow individual users instead of topics” model or the constrained character limit. Basically the same thing I infrequently used Twitter for before Elon took it over.
I’ve got an account, but don’t really use it. I’ve been thinking of maybe giving it another go lately, but haven’t yet. I do use Bluesky though. People are more chill there.
I also don’t like the twitter format. I prefer stuff grouped by topic, not user, so forums are generally preferable.
I don’t see the appeal of the microblogging format.
No, I don’t get the attraction to that medium format just like I don’t understand X, Bluesky, etc. It’s a soapbox format.
Yep. A million preachers in empty churches. I want to actually converse with people
People talk to each other all the time on Mastodon. The posts have commentors that interact with each other and the poster.
Here’s a current random trending post from Viss, who is a cybersecurtiy engineer:
https://mastodon.social/@Viss/117633193893594420
Notice he posted about something he cared about, and is talking to several people about it. This is the common experience there. Its no different than Lemmy/Reddit/etc having an OP post an article, then talking about it with people in the comments.
The only shift is that you follow people or hashtags, not communities. You can tune this pretty well to reflect your interests, just like on Lemmy.
Except the comments aren’t nested in the same way at the top level, a response is just “on your timeline, as a reply”, and most clients don’t allow sorting by likes, which would be the same as upvotes on something like lemmy.
So there’s conversation, but it’s certainly not
no differentthan something like lemmySure, but thats a formatting issue, certainty not “a million preachers in empty churches.” The medium itself matters, but there is a message there that isnt one way or as inherently vapid as its been portrayed.
Not enjoying the chronological structure is plenty of reason not to engage with it, but I find the common argument that “it has no valuable content because its users are just being egotistical” to be a pretty empty critique.
I think this is where a lot of friction comes in with social media and ends up as an under-discussed point, in that not everyone is using the same social media platforms in the same way.
Some people are trying to have conversations, some people are trying to tap into a stream of events, some people are trying to market, and some people like myself are shitposting into the void as an assertion that we’re alive. And we’re all trying to do it on the same platform while shouting past eachother.
I am much more likely to converse with people on mastodon. Here, it is a stream of isolated responses to one-off comments that may or may not be the same person; on masto, you’re talking to someone specific, instead of engaging with isolated comments. We talk about topics in relation to posts and communities; on mastodon we talk about things in relation to the human who is posting them.
Yeah same boat. I never had a Twitter so I never really got used to Bluesky. Mastodon seems too similar of a format for my taste.
I joined a masto instance and still support it financially (because fuck Elon ) but I rarely go there and when I do it’s usually just to do exactly what you said: post soapbox style
Discussion platforms like Lemmy/PieFed are IMO much more… social
I have a Mastodon account, but I only use it for testing interactions between the larger Fediverse and the Threadiverse.
I don’t really like the Twitter format, so I’ll stick with PieFed.
Yes. Because it has a great community of people who talk about the things I like
I did until I fell to a trap where some alarmist said that AI makes people not learn things, makes them delearn things and asked people for thoughts.
Turns out they didn’t really want to hear experiences and surprisingly enough they also knew better than me that I actually hadn’t learned things that I thought having learned.
Pettiness aside it’s a small and quite tighly woven group of people, which makes arguments feel more personal. Here I don’t know anyone by their handle so it’s like talking to a hivemind. There you see who’s taking who’s side and it’s quite expressive.
I liked that it doesn’t have algorithms and advertisements, but I’m not sure if that format is good mentally. It’s addictive and turns into doomscrolling easily.
For some reason I feel the need to share my thoughts in the internet so maybe I’ll continue to do so here.
Yes, I have a couple hashtags I keep open in their own column and then several more in my main feed. I don’t keep a close eye on it though I do check it a couple times a day and occasionally post about my personal projects.
I like the local community content too and population size has been good for tastes.
I had no idea what Mastodon was before reading this thread. I’m glad I did, because it sounds like it’s a Twitter alternative, which is great because fuck big tech, but the format is not my cup of tea. Oh how I miss the old forums built purely on HTML. But alas, ASCII art has sailed into The West.
Yeah, I use it because I follow a few cool Orgs there (nearly every organisation that has to do with free software is on there) and some comic artists I like (J.L. westover, Bad and Ralph Ruthe (German). And then I follow a few other cool people, that I found through other means and found out that they are on Mastodon or people I found through Mastodon.
But yeah, the main thing that keeps me coming back are the daily comics.
















