Reddit can tell when I make an alternate account to get around a bullshit site wide ban but not when a robot is pretending that they took his wife in the divorce?
If they couldn’t tell, the bots would get banned sometimes.
Okay but that’s worse. You do see how that’s worse right?
Most of the stories posted on large subreddits were imaginary anyway. Now they are just being hallucinated by an AI. Is there much of a difference?
Back in my day you actually had to be creative to get people to believe your bullshit story.
back in my day my dad would leap off the hell in a cell ring, jumper cables in hand, and everyone would clap
At the end of the day, most internet forums exist as entertainment. It doesn’t really matter whether the text is from real people or not, what matters to Reddit and other platforms is that real users show up to pump numbers and get served ads. It’s kinda like how pro sports is not latently about athleticism, it’s just another entertainment platform to get butts into seats and eyes onscreen to make a buck.
If bot content gets the eyeballs, so what? Guess the content being fictional doesn’t really matter. People don’t like being lied to, but then nobody is claiming everything you read on the internet is true in the first place.
Anyway, to all the people who imagined humanity’s future would end up looking different than WALL-E: sorry to disappoint. You’ll get a hover recliner, at least.
The communities like AITAH and relationships on reddit are completely cooked. There is so much AI nonsense and as noted, people completely eat it up.
AITAH has been mostly made up rage bait stories long time before AI nonsense. There’s nothing that generates more engagement than someone being wrong on the internet.
The difference now is that the rage bait has become automated.
AITAH for pranking my gf by putting a plastic bag over her head?
So I put a plastic bag over my gf’s head as a joke. She flailed around and punched me in the face. Then she ran off somewhere, looking mad. Why can’t she take a harmless prank? Where has humor gone these days?
The title is usually a bait and switch to get you into the comments.
AITAH for shoving a small child?
There was a bus about to hit them and I saved their life. Their mother cursed me out because the kid got a skinned knee. Half my family thinks I need to apologize. They’re blowing up my phone.
This isn’t particularly noteworthy or concerning, imo. These two communities are probably the least likely to care about authenticity, and also best suited for a system that’s only real success is spinning moderately coherent fictions. They have and will always be most interested in drama, which is easy to fabricate.
The real danger of these systems is shaping public discourse by sheer volume of noise. They can make any opinion seem overwhelmingly supported, or tear apart opposition with distractions and infighting. And they do it with a single-minded focus spread across thousands of voices.
They have and will always be most interested in drama, which is easy to fabricate.
Remember all the Reality Shows ™ that took over because they had no scripting and relatively tiny production crews? They took over because they were cheap.
Looks like AI is about to lower that bar yet again.
Those quickly became scripted and fake reality too, if any of them were ever even not that.
Sure , of course those subs don’t serve any real purpose besides entertainment. The effects of AI making up stories could be to subtly confuse people about how others think and make decisions at most. Though of course it’s useless to give advice to an AI OP, thousands of people still read and discuss what people write. Who knows, the AI stories could even seem less fake than fictional stories.
Lemmy is cooked too.
I am AI
Behold my genius!
There are two Rs in Strawberry!
No, but seriously, you’re dead right. Shit is unnerving.
I mean, there are two Rs in “strawberry.”
There’s also three Rs…but who’s counting?
Not me. I’m gay and one of the ones who can’t do math
Since when has newton been gay?
Since he invented math which is also gay
But also fake.
Basically the “reality TV” of Internet forums. Should come as no surprise, even human made stories are usually fake.
cooked without better identity mechanisms
And that worked out so well for Facebook… giving up privacy and anonymity is not the solution, watch that last step, it’s a doozy.
Those who would sacrifice liberty for security, deserve neither and will get none.
Indeed. My dream internet is anonymous
I don’t think that’s what they meant by identity mechanisms. Or at least I hope not. It’s just not enough to require an e-mail to verify that you are in fact a valid user
Funny this coming from Twitter. Nothing but Nazi bots left in that cesspool.
Hey that’s not true! There’s still plenty of hentai still there too
We could use public libraries to do some kind of “are you a human” confirmation. I.e. you get a digitally signed token proving that you are a human, that you can use on the internet to show that you are human. Only the library has to be trusted by the public …
And then you take that token and give it to your AI…?
Well, no, that wouldn’t work you see, because that would be lying.
yes, but at least you can’t easily create 10000 bots at once. you could only create 1 bot at a time, and that would already do a lot.
I’m not so much worried about 1 person using AI to write their comments; I’m way more worried about large political parties making 10000 bots to support their agenda (propaganda) or companies creating a lot of bots to create hype about their products (advertisement).
How would you verify that you are a human? The only ways I can really think of are enormously invasive
walk up to your library in person and let them give you a chip card that contains an (anonymous) private key, or let them verify your fediverse account somehow, both methods would be without you showing them any kind of ID card.
They would at least need to have your ID on record, so they know you aren’t just getting a new private key at a different library every day. That said, I’d be happy with it if that record only showed that my ID had been used to acquire such a key, without any link between the ID and the key
So is this going to only work with fediverse accounts or are you gonna try and teach people about public/private keys?
And what happens when that database leaks and someone starts using your key to post illegal things? Or should we use password rules and have your library generate you a new key for every platform?
Could just do MFA checks for all posts, comments, and upvotes. Imagine?
It would cut out the slop about 99%
Dissent detected, officers en route
Removed by mod
MFA helps boost security of an account. It would do nothing to prove a user is human or not.
Maybe Elon was on to something when Grok tagged everything with an unrelated diatribe about farmers in south Africa. Perhaps every AI model needs to be an activist about one random topic so we can tell them apart. Or ya know, maybe congress could do stuff to require their output be reverse searchable so we could just match up the output to what people say…
Hot take : we need one social network where everyone’s identity is verified. No one is anonymous, everything you post publicly is linked to your real name.
Not every social media, anonymity is also good.
I’d prefer anonymous users verified by real identity.
It’d take some thought as to how you properly establish accounts are owned by individuals but it’s not impossible.
