We seriously need to differentiate servers, otherwise the decentralization is useless.

  • Pika@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    20
    ·
    11 hours ago

    Someone in another post showed a decent site that shows cloudflare dependency, so I threw the top 35 actives from observer into it. It’s honestly not as bad as I expected it would be, but it is concerning.

    Lemmy

    lemmy.world(Active Users: 14512): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    sh.itjust.works(Active Users: 2509): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    lemmy.ml(Active Users: 2087): Cloudflare? No

    lemmy.zip(Active Users: 1704): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    lemmy.dbzer0.com(Active Users: 1444): Cloudflare? No

    lemmy.ca(Active Users: 1381): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    lemmygrad.ml(Active Users: 972): Cloudflare? No

    lemmy.blahaj.zone(Active Users: 956): Cloudflare? No

    programming.dev(Active Users: 929): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    discuss.tchncs.de(Active Users: 778): Cloudflare? No

    sopuli.xyz(Active Users: 596): Cloudflare? No

    slrpnk.net(Active Users: 371): Cloudflare? No

    infosec.pub(Active Users: 331): Cloudflare? No

    lemmy.today(Active Users: 314): Cloudflare? No

    midwest.social(Active Users: 307): Cloudflare? No

    reddthat.com(Active Users: 292): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    feddit.nl(Active Users: 290): Cloudflare? No

    pawb.social(Active Users: 243): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    forum.guncadindex.com(Active Users: 234): Cloudflare? No

    mander.xyz(Active Users: 194): Cloudflare? No

    lemmings.world(Active Users: 177): Cloudflare? No

    ani.social(Active Users: 173): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    feddit.it(Active Users: 158): Cloudflare? No

    startrek.website(Active Users: 156): Cloudflare? No

    feddit.dk(Active Users: 151): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,cname)

    leminal.space(Active Users: 126): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    ttrpg.network(Active Users: 125): Cloudflare? No

    szmer.info(Active Users: 116): Cloudflare? No

    lemmy.eco.br(Active Users: 99): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,proxy,cname)

    lemy.lol(Active Users: 97): Cloudflare? Yes(dns,cname)

    awful.systems(Active Users: 90): Cloudflare? No

    • Cricket [he/him]@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      5
      ·
      9 hours ago

      It looks like that source also didn’t list hexbear.net, which seems to be around the 5th or 6th largest Lemmy instance, at 1.57k monthly active users. Results from the site you linked (thanks, by the way) say that they use Cloudflare for DNS but not for CDN/Proxy/SSL.

      Hexbear and lemmynsfw aren’t listed on fedidb either, which leads me to believe that they must block whatever discovery mechanism is being used by these fedi stats sites.

      • Pika@sh.itjust.works
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        11 hours ago

        I used observer and sorted by active users, so maybe fediverse observer doesn’t host the instance due to the NSFW? idk