I loved iGoogle. I had my feeds set up just how I liked them. Then I moved to protopage when that went to the graveyard. Then a bunch of things (not everything) stopped updating.
I went back to check it out a few weeks ago and even fewer things were updating. A lot of places just let RSS fall by the wayside.
I think it depends on what you’re after. I like to bullshit, but mainly I’m looking up product reviews from real people instead of professional reviewers, how to do some niche crap in one of my million hobbies, and getting technical info. Speaking only for myself a big ol’ group is better.
For someone who wants to build and participate in community, make connections with folks who share the same interests, and talk to the same folks all the time a small and caring community is going to be much better.
With all that nonsense being said, I’m not going to be upset no matter how it turns out. I’ll hang out, talk about drinking and whatever food I want to make, and try to find my answers here first.