• 3 Posts
  • 90 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 14th, 2023

help-circle
  • Boaty McBoatFace was NOT a debacle. It was a once-in-a-generation opportunity to get kids interested in climate science with programs like “The diary of Boaty McBoatFace” or “Zoom call with a Boaty McBoatScientist” all around the world in classrooms. Hell, even in high school I would’ve taken an elective that was doing actual work if it was Boaty McBoatFace-themed*.

    *not to say that I’m young enough to have been in high school at the time, but that it would appeal to kids that old

    The debacle was that they were too stuck up to realize what a gift they’d been given and completely squandered it. Boaty McBoatFace was beautiful. For a couple days, the internet cared about science in the absence of technology.


  • I get where you’re coming from, but I don’t think that you’re quite understanding the role of school? In school they teach you one programming language so you can learn many. You might be the most comfortable with Java, but you’ll quickly see why you need to witch. And sure, we were taught how to use a bunch of Mac-only programs, but more than that we were taught how basic UX of programs works, how to use the internet, how to search with keywords, I think a bit later on Google existed and we were taught how to use the advanced search. All of this is very transferable knowledge, even if you feel most at home somewhere.

    Also keep in mind most kids in school are not blindly doing what school says to do outside of school and building heavily into the ecosystem they were told to do. Certainly not those who are using APIs.

    Anyway I guess my point is, it is much better to learn something than nothing, and foundational knowledge is the point. In this case, it does not matter so much what you learn, and you are best off deep diving into something kids already have a bit of familiarity with, so that they can build onto existing knowledge.

    Edit: Although, I would agree with you if this is like, an advanced LLM programming class. In that case for sure an OSS version should be preferred. But this sounds like basic LLM literacy?





  • Yeah if you look at my profile I’m modding 7 magazines:

    • Two I’m posting frequently to, and no one else posts there
    • One, I was the owner of on reddit in the first place
    • One I was a heavy contributor to on reddit, and I left an open offer to mods to take over
    • One I was a heavy contributor to on reddit, but the mods on reddit were inactive so I didn’t leave that notice
    • The other two I had nothing to do with, but I was in a discord convo where someone was bemoaning their lack so I said “ok I’ll create them, then you can post” and I’m pretty sure I left a note that subreddit mods are free to take them from me, but yeah if anyone wrote me and said “why are you sitting on TalesFromTechSupport” my first response would be, “do you want it?”

  • Why would people want to invest time and effort into building up a magazine that’s under control of a name squatter?

    I think you (and OP) are rewriting history a little bit. People enthusiastically created many magazines in the first days of the migration so that they would already exist and people would post to them. I do not think many people (if anyone) created magazines because they wanted to own them. In fact, if you look at many of the descriptions they say things like “reddit mods contact me if you want to take this over.”

    So yes, post to them.






  • oh hi

    there’s a couple issues to consider with this that come to mind immediately

    1. large difference in subscriber count, and intentionality of posting to a smaller community, not wanting larger traffic (e.g. /m/TrueTrueTrueTrueWorldNews doesn’t want the traffic from /m/AnimeTitties or /m/WorldNews or whatever the main one is called)
    2. the same link can be posted to different communities for drastically different reasons, e.g. a headline “Alot of new fantasy releases this summer” gets posted to /m/alot for the grammar mistake, /m/fantasy for book reviews, and /m/journalism for critiquing the writing. All three could be similar size (I can only pretend /m/alot is this popular) but no one wants to see grammar purists on /m/fantasy, and no one on /m/journalism actually cares about the book recs themselves, just the article format

    edit wow /r/ is a deeply ingrained muscle memory