Well, this is /MildlyInfuriating and not /Privacy, so I’ll just say that I very much don’t like Facebook and all its spinoff products (or acquired, in the case of WhatsApp).
I will say, Facebook didn’t spend $21 billion on WhatsApp and not expect some kind of return on that investment. Classic WhatsApp charged $1 a year. There’s no way that’s profitable. I don’t think it asks for that money anymore. I think just selling your data/snooping on your business is enough.
There is a somewhat interesting solution, though it’s hardly cheap, or practical in many cases. Have one phone be your daily driver and you’re signed into it with your personal accounts and you have stuff on it you trust. Then you have another phone that is not so easily trusted. You sign in to the provider (be it Apple or Google) with a dummy account that is not related to you, and you install these apps you don’t trust. You don’t give the phone location permissions, and you don’t activate it as a cell phone (no SIM card or eSIM). You use it as a WiFi device and hotspot it off your phone or home WiFi. Do the shady stuff (e.g. WhatsApp, TikTok, etc.) on that. If your main phone has a VPN on it, even better, because the other phone can use network location to help identify you. If you’re always in different places, good luck with that.
The main problem with this (from a stock android perspective) is Google play services. Your private phone/daily driver would literally have to be a non-stock rom or one that doesn’t come with Google play services installed at all. Because otherwise Google and other companies linked to them will fingerprint your device and link it that way because those two devices are often in the same place at the same time or on the same network at the same or similar times etc. The and even when you think you’ve given the apps no permissions, Google has a habit of turning this stuff on (location data, telemetry etc) and gathering it in the background.
I had a Motorola phone that had three profiles. It was really just home screen layouts though. This was in 2012? Proton/Electrify (4G/3G versions). Way ahead of its time.
I went iPhone before Google implemented profiles. I have an old S10, I wonder if it has the feature.
Well, this is /MildlyInfuriating and not /Privacy, so I’ll just say that I very much don’t like Facebook and all its spinoff products (or acquired, in the case of WhatsApp).
I will say, Facebook didn’t spend $21 billion on WhatsApp and not expect some kind of return on that investment. Classic WhatsApp charged $1 a year. There’s no way that’s profitable. I don’t think it asks for that money anymore. I think just selling your data/snooping on your business is enough.
There is a somewhat interesting solution, though it’s hardly cheap, or practical in many cases. Have one phone be your daily driver and you’re signed into it with your personal accounts and you have stuff on it you trust. Then you have another phone that is not so easily trusted. You sign in to the provider (be it Apple or Google) with a dummy account that is not related to you, and you install these apps you don’t trust. You don’t give the phone location permissions, and you don’t activate it as a cell phone (no SIM card or eSIM). You use it as a WiFi device and hotspot it off your phone or home WiFi. Do the shady stuff (e.g. WhatsApp, TikTok, etc.) on that. If your main phone has a VPN on it, even better, because the other phone can use network location to help identify you. If you’re always in different places, good luck with that.
The main problem with this (from a stock android perspective) is Google play services. Your private phone/daily driver would literally have to be a non-stock rom or one that doesn’t come with Google play services installed at all. Because otherwise Google and other companies linked to them will fingerprint your device and link it that way because those two devices are often in the same place at the same time or on the same network at the same or similar times etc. The and even when you think you’ve given the apps no permissions, Google has a habit of turning this stuff on (location data, telemetry etc) and gathering it in the background.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-11-02/social-media-ban-algorithm-phone-addiction-instagram-x-tiktok-/105844066
https://www.howtogeek.com/how-google-tracks-and-scans-everything-on-your-android-device/
I use android and have work mode enabled that only has contacts for WhatsApp.
The personal side of my phone has all my contacts and has aurora store, new pipe etc…
Nice. I might have to look into that sometime.
I had a Motorola phone that had three profiles. It was really just home screen layouts though. This was in 2012? Proton/Electrify (4G/3G versions). Way ahead of its time.
I went iPhone before Google implemented profiles. I have an old S10, I wonder if it has the feature.