Well, if you asked an idiot, Czechia might be defined as part of Antarctica.
The people we should ask are the Czechs.
And anyone who empathises with them will agree, it’s in central Europe.
This is not just a geographic discussion. It’s a question of whether you respect their 1000 year history of important kings and prince electors of the holy roman empire, or if you just look at the 80 years of forceful soviet occupation.
Compare traditional Czech dishes with Bavarian and with Russian dishes, you will see.
It definitely seems like a topic some are very emotional about and not just a simple geographic grouping. But I was just saying that those differing definitions exist still
I feel like you’re a bit confused about what the discussion is
FYI Czechia is not considered eastern Europe, but central Europe
Depends who you ask and what the context is
That’s shown by both the article for Eastern Europe mentioning how it is sometimes included and how it’s sometimes not included in Central Europe from your article. The article you linked just says it’s often included but that’s again what I was saying, it’s only “often” because it depends.
It’s almost always considered to be part of Central Europe. I’m aware that especially thanks to Europes troubled past, a lot of the views have changed, but according to every recent view that topic it’s very clear.
Besides that, I have enough Czech friends who share my opinion on that matter and obviously their word matters more in that regard than yours or mine.
But you are unfortunately confused. I’m not arguing for their grouping in either category. I’m simply saying what they’re considered as depends on who you ask and what the context is. And that has been shown to be the case by both of us, even if you did it accidentally with your link and what you said just now.
You can repeat as often as you want, but that doesn’t make me confused.
By any modern views the Czech Republic is in Central Europe, look at any map. The context in which you’d be absolutely correct, is an old view, especially 1947-1991. But I’m talking about the here and now.
Maybe you are confused.
I guess it’s best to just end this back and forth.
I feel like you were (and I feel like still are) arguing as if I held some position on this and weren’t just saying how the status of Czech Republic depends on who you ask and what the context is. And that’s true, even though you consider those views outdated. So that definitely confused me
I guess it’s best to just end this back and forth.
I’m surprised this even turned into back and forth tbh.
For a reminder, this was my point: Depends who you ask and what the context is
And both articles say exactly that… Even your article starts with
Well, if you asked an idiot, Czechia might be defined as part of Antarctica.
The people we should ask are the Czechs.
And anyone who empathises with them will agree, it’s in central Europe.
This is not just a geographic discussion. It’s a question of whether you respect their 1000 year history of important kings and prince electors of the holy roman empire, or if you just look at the 80 years of forceful soviet occupation.
Compare traditional Czech dishes with Bavarian and with Russian dishes, you will see.
It definitely seems like a topic some are very emotional about and not just a simple geographic grouping. But I was just saying that those differing definitions exist still
And if you read more than the beginning you’ll find out that the Czech Republic is almost universally defined as a part of Central Europe.
I feel like you’re a bit confused about what the discussion is
That’s shown by both the article for Eastern Europe mentioning how it is sometimes included and how it’s sometimes not included in Central Europe from your article. The article you linked just says it’s often included but that’s again what I was saying, it’s only “often” because it depends.
Not confused at all, thank you.
It’s almost always considered to be part of Central Europe. I’m aware that especially thanks to Europes troubled past, a lot of the views have changed, but according to every recent view that topic it’s very clear. Besides that, I have enough Czech friends who share my opinion on that matter and obviously their word matters more in that regard than yours or mine.
But you are unfortunately confused. I’m not arguing for their grouping in either category. I’m simply saying what they’re considered as depends on who you ask and what the context is. And that has been shown to be the case by both of us, even if you did it accidentally with your link and what you said just now.
You can repeat as often as you want, but that doesn’t make me confused.
By any modern views the Czech Republic is in Central Europe, look at any map. The context in which you’d be absolutely correct, is an old view, especially 1947-1991. But I’m talking about the here and now. Maybe you are confused. I guess it’s best to just end this back and forth.
I feel like you were (and I feel like still are) arguing as if I held some position on this and weren’t just saying how the status of Czech Republic depends on who you ask and what the context is. And that’s true, even though you consider those views outdated. So that definitely confused me
I’m surprised this even turned into back and forth tbh.