• brbposting@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    edit-2
    4 hours ago

    Astrology is really dumb. I do have one curiosity with it. It’s a big deal for hockey players to be born early in the year to the point you find fewer pros born in December and in the later months compared to January through March born hockey professionals.

    One other thing, kids have birthdays every year and if they have their parties outside that means some kids are having snowy birthday parties and others are having sunny birthdays and plenty of crossover. The kinds of interactions you have with your friends will be slightly impacted* by how much outdoor gear you have to wear, etc. (*maybe imperceptibly)

    But the point is there are at least two possible differences that come depending on which month you’re born in. What if there are like a hundred of them and astrology is a really terrible way of trying to figure that out? Now I realize it’s not so maybe a better question is I wonder if there is any version of birth month based assessments, correlations, or analyses that might be fruitful or useful in some way or another.

    • sp3ctr4l@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      edit-2
      2 hours ago

      Ok you seem genuienly curious here, lemme try.

      So, yes, you are correct that the season you are born in will slightly effect the number of seasons a kid experiences.

      But uh… what if you are born in a tropical monsoon climate that has no winter?

      What if you are born in the other hemisphere, where the seasons are inverted?

      What if you can’t afford a house, so you don’t have a yard for parties, don’t live near a park… or hockey rink?

      And the biggest one: what do the actual stars have to do with this?

      Say earth and the whole solar system are poofed out of the Milky Way, and into Andromeda. Solar system remains stable, all orbits the same, the Sun’s massive solar wind is strong enough to protect us from the ambient radiation of wherever we end up.

      Seasons will be exactly the same. Stars will be dramatically different. … Do you think the stars being different would change… anything?

      Beyond that, even back here on normal, real Earth, in the Milky Way… most Eastern astrology is based on the year you are born in. Not the month.

      And also, throughout history… various cultures have kept a calendar, kept track of time… in many different ways. Solar calendars. Lunar calendars. Calendars based on the reigns of Emperors or Dynasties, calendars based off of mythical/religious stories for the origin of the universe/planet.

      They also have not all recognized the same constellation patterns… as what we now recognize them as.

      If you’re in the Southern hemisphere… you can’t even see many of the ones we see in the North.

      You can try and number crunch statistical correlations between every possible variable.

      Sometimes this can lead to an insight.

      But to nail down why that correlation exists, to actually discover something true and useful… you also have to provide a causal mechanism that makes sense.

      The object close enough to meaningfully directly affect Earth is the Moon. It causes tides, for example, alters many animal behaviors.

      The only other thing is the Sun, of course, which gives the planet light and energy.

      Nothing else inside of or outside of our solar system has any mechanism of directly impacting life on Earth in a regular, noticeable way…

      … unless we get astounsingly unlucky and get hit by the radiation from a magnetar we somehow haven’t noticed yet, or something absurd like that.